Is the Higher Criticism Scholarly?
'Is the Higher Criticism Scholarly?' Summary
"Is the Higher Criticism Scholarly?", Robert Dick Wilson argues that the Higher Criticism, a method of biblical criticism that seeks to understand the origins and development of the Bible, is not scholarly. He contends that the Higher Critics rely on subjective assumptions and interpretations, and that their conclusions are often based on faulty translations of the Hebrew Bible.
Wilson begins by defining the Higher Criticism. He writes that the Higher Critics "seek to determine the date, authorship, and sources of the various books of the Bible, and to reconstruct the history of Israel and Judah on the basis of these findings." He then goes on to argue that the Higher Critics' methods are flawed.
One of Wilson's main criticisms of the Higher Critics is that they rely on subjective assumptions. He writes that "the Higher Critics are constantly making assumptions about the motives and intentions of the biblical writers, and these assumptions are often based on their own personal biases." He also argues that the Higher Critics' interpretations of the Bible are often based on faulty translations. He writes that "the Higher Critics often rely on translations of the Hebrew Bible that are inaccurate or misleading."
Wilson concludes his book by arguing that the Higher Criticism is not scholarly. He writes that "the Higher Critics' methods are flawed, their assumptions are subjective, and their interpretations are often based on faulty translations." He also argues that the Higher Critics' conclusions are often harmful to the Christian faith. He writes that "the Higher Critics' conclusions have led many people to doubt the reliability of the Bible, and this has had a negative impact on the Christian faith."
Wilson's book was well-received by conservative Christian scholars, who praised his defense of the Bible. However, the book was also criticized by liberal Christian scholars, who accused Wilson of being biased and of misrepresenting the Higher Criticism.
Despite the controversy, Wilson's book remains an important work in the debate over the Higher Criticism. It is a well-argued and well-researched book that provides a valuable critique of the Higher Criticism's methods and conclusions.
Book Details
Language
EnglishOriginal Language
EnglishPublished In
1922Genre/Category
Tags/Keywords
Author
Robert Dick Wilson
United States
Robert Dick Wilson was a renowned American scholar, linguist, and theologian, best known for his contributions to biblical studies and his expertise in Semitic languages. Born on February 4, 1856, in...
More on Robert Dick WilsonDownload eBooks
Listen/Download Audiobook
- Select Speed
Related books
The Treasury of David, Vol. 5 by Charles H. Spurgeon
Delve into the profound and captivating world of the Psalms as Charles H. Spurgeon unlocks the hidden treasures of praise, lament, and trust in "The T...
Catholic and Anti-Catholic History by Various
G.K. Chesterton and James Walsh join Hilaire Belloc in an energetic rollout of the means by which history becomes propaganda, to the damage, not only...
On the Babylonian Captivity of the Church by Martin Luther
Prelude on the Babylonian Captivity of the Church was the second of the three major treatises published by Martin Luther in 1520, coming after the Add...
History of the Inquisition of Spain, Vol. 4 by Henry Charles Lea
The fourth and final volume of Lea's monumental work on the Spanish Inquisition. This volume discusses how the Inquisition dealt with mysticism, solic...
Is War Diminishing? by Frederick Adams Woods
It argues that despite the many technological advancements of the modern world, war is not diminishing, but is instead becoming more frequent and more...
The Imitation of Christ by Thomas a Kempis
The Imitation of Christ is a Christian devotional book by Thomas à Kempis, first composed in Latin (as De Imitatione Christi) c. 1418–1427. It is a ha...
Flowers from the Garden of Saint Francis for Every Day of the Year by St. Francis of Assisi
This is a collection of 365 moral admonitions of Saint Francis of Assisi (1182-1226) and other notable Franciscans. The compiler of this anthology sug...
On Adulterous Marriages by Saint Augustine of Hippo
It explores the controversial issue of marriage and adultery from a moral and religious perspective. Augustine's writing style is characterized by it...
The Journal of a Disappointed Man by W. N. P. Barbellion
A young man's candid and often humorous account of his struggle to come to terms with his own mortality. The Journal of a Disappointed Man is a diary...
The Master's Indwelling by Andrew Murray
In all the writings of the late nineteenth century minister and writer Andrew Murray, we see his passion for reality in the lives of Christian believe...
Reviews for Is the Higher Criticism Scholarly?
No reviews posted or approved, yet...